Love + Sex

Monday, November 30, 2009

FYI, Guys Really Don't Want to Marry The Kinds of Women I Keep Seeing in Summer Blockbusters

0617-hangover.jpg
Any of you people see ‘The Hangover’? Am I the only one who sees a reversion to H-wood’s ‘Stepford Wives’ era?

I’m going to get to the ‘The Hangover’ in a minute. But let me start with the movie that seemingly all other dude comedies are trying to be like: ‘Knocked Up.’

Listen, I love me some Judd Apatow. I could have watched ‘Knocked Up’ seventeen times. (Actually, I think I did watch 'Knocked Up' 17 times. Thanks HBO!) But there was something about the Leslie Mann character that always made me squirm.

See our tips: Justin Timberlake’s Dating Dos & Don’ts

I don’t know. Maybe it was that she plays a castrating, neurotic, vindictive, sexless wife?

And that she was supposed to be some kind of wifely archetype. Her purpose was to show our young, fuzzy and impressionable Ben (played by Seth Rogan) what wives are like, should he decide to make an honest woman out of Alison (played by Katherine Heigl).

Cut to Rachel Harris in ‘The Hangover.’ She plays Melissa, Stu’ girlfriend. And she makes "Knocked Up"'s Debbie look like a barrel of laughs. I mean humorless doesn’t even begin to describe it. She’s not a wife, she’s Gestapo. She may as well wear Stu's manhood around her neck on a lovely gold chain.

Is that how they think guys really feel about their girlfriends? It’s not how my friends feel about their girlfriends.

And then there’s the other wife figure in ‘The Hangover’: the woman who’s supposed to marry the bachelor in this bachelor party movie. She’s painted as the perfect woman, the opposite of Stu's girlfriend. She “lets” her fiancé go to Vegas. She never bothers him when he doesn’t come back when he said he would. And when it looks like he won’t actually make the "wedding" part of the wedding, even though all the guests are there, she tells him, you know, she’s getting a little freaked out.

That’s not a girlfriend. That’s a lobotomy with c-cups.

That’s a modern Stepford Wife. It’s like, as men, we’re supposed to yearn for a human sex doll with no opinions or will of her own, a woman we can introduce to our friends by saying, ‘Isn’t she great! She looks awesome and barely speaks!’

What gives? Were you guys as bummed out about these characters as I was? Did your guy friends dig those movies?

Related: What Men Say vs. What Men Actually Mean

MORE FROM MARRIED JAKE:

Get Glamour Wherever You Go! Follow us on Twitter. Friend us on Facebook. Add us to your Google homepage.

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 33
  • Black Cat's Avatar
    Posted by Black Cat Thu Jul 2, 2009 6:03am PDT

    I have to say, I've never seen 'knocked up', but i did see 'hangover'. HILARIOUS! I did notice, now looking back on it, the character stereotypes, regarding Stu's girlfriend (a real piece of work btw) and the bride-to-be. I can't even say anything about Stu's girlfriend - saying she looked like she would wear his manhood around her neck is enough lol. But I didn't really feel like the bride was a doormat. The groom's a grown man, and he can go to Vegas if he wants. Hell, I'd go to Vegas! And she did try to reach him on everyone's cells. She seemed more to me as the bride all men want - the one who knows what you're doing in Vegas, but know she may end up doing the same thing so she backs off some.

    Who knows.....

    Report Abuse
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Thu Jul 2, 2009 6:08am PDT

    Right....."J.J.M" sometimes I can't stand you, sometimes I totally understand you, if you hadn't attacked me before, I would of thought you were a cool guy.

    Report Abuse
  • Jlowe's Avatar
    Posted by Jlowe Thu Jul 2, 2009 6:28am PDT

    I agree with the other post....men who abandon their single friends are not captives.....they make a choice. It is just not the one you like

    Report Abuse
  • pwsgirl's Avatar
    Posted by pwsgirl Thu Jul 2, 2009 6:29am PDT

    I haven't seen these movies, but I have to agree with the posters who say they dislike the characters that are nothing like real-life men and women. I don't understand how anyone can truly enjoy a movie when they can't relate at all to the characters, whether they see a bit of themselves in those people or someone that they might know. I am an author of tasteful fictional romance (in other words, no sexually explicit material), and the one thing I made sure of was that my characters are all the types of people my readers can relate to. No far out there, do-these-types-of-people-really-exist types for me. I think the movies should do the same thing, although I have to say, in their defense, that they probably don't in most cases because they feel somehow that the movie goers are just looking for something to watch where they don't actually have to think for that two hours and actually try to analyze in the end. Just my two cents.

    Report Abuse
  • Brianna's Avatar
    Posted by Brianna Thu Jul 2, 2009 6:40am PDT

    I definitely agree with sweet and married Jake. They make so many points and to answer Married Jake's question all of my guy friends hated it. They have never wanted bimbos with empty heads. All they're good for (and i quote) are headache below the belt and above

    Report Abuse
  • eccc's Avatar
    Posted by eccc Thu Jul 2, 2009 6:48am PDT

    Why do marriages have to be like this? Just b/c we get married does not mean the fun has to end. And to all the controlling husbands/wives out there: GETTING MARRIED DOES NOT GIVE YOU THE GREEN LIGHT TO BECOME A NAG OR STALKER. A good marriage is based on mutual respect especially when your hubby is out drinkin with the guys. Why don't you have a girl's night the following weekend?

    Report Abuse
  • Trish's Avatar
    Posted by Trish Thu Jul 2, 2009 8:18am PDT

    The portrayal of the women in those movies bothered me too! They aren't real characters; they are the embodiment of some screenwriter's fantasies. I'm glad I'm not the only one who noticed.

    Report Abuse
  • SometimesHappy's Avatar
    Posted by SometimesHappy Thu Jul 2, 2009 9:12am PDT

    I have a pet peeve about the aweful nagging wife stereotype.

    I just got married a few weeks ago and my husband and I have gotten into a fight or two since then. Everytime we get into an arguement now he mentions something about "nagging" or "trying to change him". I asked him about this, because it seems to me he is being over senseative about some things I say to him. He said it's because of all the horror stories hes heard about being married. Before we were even married he heard awful things like "you can get a divorce with in 90 days for $200" or "shes taking your manhood" or "your lifes over with now".

    It's ingrained in him that no matter how much he loved me before we got married and no matter how fun and accepting I've always been, I WILL turn into that aweful, controling, freak that is considered a wife. And that sucks, because woman are taught that marriage is spiritual and one of the best momments of their life! Men are taught to run for the hills!

    And anouther point, sometimes those woman aren't what they seem. Don't believe everything your buddys tells you. My husbands friends or family will ask him if he wants to do something on Tuesday. Tuesday comes and he deciedes he didn't want to go. Instead of telling his friends he didn't want to go, he says something like "Oh, the wife was too tired" or "the wife just wanted to stay home" or "the wife needed me to do things around the house". So his friends and family start to think I'm the one keeping them from him, but it's not true. You find out later when they start asking if you were feeling any better because your husband didn't go to his nephews baseball game because he saidvyou were sick... when your weren't sick and your husband just didn't feel like going!

    Report Abuse
  • hey you's Avatar
    Posted by hey you Thu Jul 2, 2009 2:10pm PDT

    I loved Knocked up! Way funny! I love Seth and Judd and the women played their characters beautifully. I loved the Hangover too. It was way funny. Of course the characters were way overboard. The only reason anyone gets offended is because they see a little bit of themselves in these characters. Every woman acts like a crazy person at one time or another. And every man has done something so stupid they deserve to be treated like children that is what makes this stuff funny. It's almost true to life.....

    Report Abuse
  • sillerious's Avatar
    Posted by sillerious Thu Jul 2, 2009 8:48pm PDT

    i have watched a few of those "comedies" recently and in no way can i relate to the women that are shown. they are either braindead or hysterical. the guys are scumbags and so far away from real men its really disturbing. besides, every "comedy" i have watched degraded women because at some point there will be boobs and butts (heaven knows whats funny about that)

    either way, i couldn't laugh, couldn't smile and was not entertained.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 33

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?