Parenting

Monday, November 30, 2009

Is Shouting Really the New Spanking?

by Risa Green (Tales from the Mommy Track)
A friend of mine forwarded me a New York Times article that ran last week, called “For Some Parents, Shouting Is the New Spanking.” In this article, it talked about how our generation is comprised of parents who don’t hit their children, but instead yell, mostly “when [we] feel irritable or anxious.” Several psychologists are quoted in the article, many of whom run centers with names like The Family Research Laboratory and The Center for the Study of Interpersonal Acceptance and Rejection. One such psychologist pointed out that yelling may be “damaging to a child’s sense of well-being and self-esteem.” Another concluded that his “bottom-line recommendation is don’t yell,” because it can be “a risk factor for a family.”

When I first read this article, I felt guilty and horrible, because I do yell at my kids. It tends to happen when they ignore me, or, most notably, at bed time, when my son and I have nightly screaming matches that escalate faster than the Cuban Missile Crisis. Mind you, I don’t feel good about it. Most nights, my son and I are usually both in tears. But there’s really only so many times that he can yell, “mommy, one more thing,” as I’m walking away from his room before I completely lose my s---. But oh, to see those words in print – “damaging to well-being and self-esteem,” “risk factor for a family” – it certainly hit me where it hurts.

And yet, after thinking about it for a few minutes, I stopped feeling guilty, and I started to feel really, really pissed off. I mean, yeah, I yell at my kids. We all do. And anyone who says they don’t is either lying or heavily, heavily medicated. Of course, I don’t verbally abuse my children. I never say mean or disparaging things to them. But yes, when I am irritable, anxious, or just plain mad because my kids do not listen to me, then I raise my voice. And you know something? I think its okay. I think those psychologists at their Centers for Being Perfect and Non-Human Parents can go f*** themselves. Really. Because what I’ve realized, is that my goal as a parent is not to raise my children without any distress whatsoever. No. My goal as a parent is to do the best that I can, and to accept that sometimes, I am going to cause my children distress. I try not to yell, but sometimes, I’m going to yell. I’m human, for God’s sake, and children, on occasion, can be really freaking irritating. There’s a reason they say it takes a village to raise them; it’s so that when your kid is being annoying, you can pass him off to someone else for a little while so that you can go get a massage. But unfortunately, I don’t live in a village. I live in a city, in a house, with a husband who plays softball two nights a week and on Saturday mornings, and I defy any one of those psychologists quoted in that article to come over here one night and try putting my son to bed without bursting a blood vessel.

Read More...

--
Risa Green, author of Tales from the Mommy Track on MommyTracked.com, lives in Los Angeles. In the last four years, she has produced two children, called Harper and Davis, and two novels, called Notes from the Underbelly and Tales from the Crib. Her third novel will be published next year.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1 of 1
  • Sukii's Avatar
    Posted by Sukii Mon Oct 26, 2009 2:48pm PDT

    I dont think always yellin, i think it depends on what u yell about, i mean if u yell b/c ur child is usin the wrong shampoo bottle then.....why couldnt u just come up to the kid and gently pick the bottle out of their hands and explain gently?

    i dont think yelling is bad at all but alot of time if u yell over everything and or almost all the time, eventually doin so loses its meaning and u just become someone who has a bad temper.

    teaching a child is important but there are other ways to teach a child too, u cant always just yell at them or just spank them.

    My sis got yelled at for using the wrong bottle -.- it was unreasonable in my opinion.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1 of 1

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.