Parenting

Sunday, November 22, 2009

Is modeling a good job for kids?

The Wall Street Journal reports that more kids than ever are going after modeling careers. Citing a slow economy, the rise of models-turned-TV-personalities like Tyra Banks, and the influence of reality shows  like "Toddlers and Tiaras" and "Little Miss Perfect", top agencies like Wilhelmina, Funnyface Today and Peak Models & Talent say they have seen the numbers of child applicants grow--in one case as much as 50%--in the past few years.

So what's the problem?

Apparently, the record numbers are setting kids up for record rejections. And while kids can experience rejection in all sorts of ways--at the hands of friends, or being picked last for a team sport--rejection that is based solely on physical appearance has its unique problems.

One mother of a young girl who has yet to land a job (despite both of her older siblings making it into catalogs) says that her daughter is "a little sad," adding, "We've explained to her the best way that we can that for different reasons they are looking for different looks."

Syd Brown, clinical and neuropsychologist in Bethesda, MD, says, "Children at a really young age have no idea of what is conceptually involved in this. They don't know that if your body changes in the wrong way, you may not be wanted anymore."

Some parents, like Natacha Andrews, whose 4-year-old daughter  would like to be the next Tyra, acknowledges the inherent contradiction in "teaching her that how people look is not supposed to be the most important thing, and then saying, 'Oh put on your pretty clothes and smile.' "

Jill Ormond, a mother whose two youngest children model, disagrees. "It's something that I think is fun, and it doesn't hurt the child," she says. "It's a way that they can have a little money set aside, and if it's not touched for 18 years, I think that's a good chunk of change."

What do you think? Is experiencing job rejection based on looks a good way for kids to develop coping mechanisms, or just another roadblock on the path toward loving themselves for who they are? Would you--or do you--let your kids model?

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 51
  • Appletini's Avatar
    Posted by Appletini Wed Nov 4, 2009 1:31pm PST

    OMG. Let me tell you a true story. Like seven or eight years ago, I photographed a little girl who was a professional model at the age of five. She had been featured in magazine ads and such... and her mom was rolling her hair and putting lip gloss/make up. What broke my heart was that she said "Mommy.. when will this be over so I can play?"

    I also photographed portfolios for child models and parents would send them tarted up for a shoot. I sent them home explaining age appropriate attire. I know it is trendy for kids to participate in Gap ads and such.. but to make them work full time is ridiculous. I wouldn't let my kid model professionally unless it was 18. It is a full time job and rejection is part of the game, but why expose them to all that early? I think that kids should take drama/dance for fun only and let them build a healthy sense of self before getting into the other stuff.

    Report Abuse
  • Dollface's Avatar
    Posted by Dollface Wed Nov 4, 2009 4:08pm PST

    If your going to let your child or teen daughter be a model I highly recommend THing of beauty by stephen fried about supermodel Gia, she started modeling at age 18 became a herion addic and died of aids at the age 26

    Report Abuse
  • Rachel_PPC's Avatar
    Posted by Rachel_PPC Thu Nov 5, 2009 6:43am PST

    I completely disagree with pageants and child modeling. It teaches children that looks override everything else, and to be honest, I find young girls made up to look like adults and prancing around in swimsuits utterly repugnant. If, as an adult, your child wants to pursue a career in modeling, that's just fine...provided you tell her how fleeting a career like that can be, and the temptations that come along with it.

    Report Abuse
  • another hockey fan's Avatar
    Posted by another hockey fan Thu Nov 5, 2009 7:01am PST

    I love the way the parents who have their daughters in these kiddie pageants keep emphasizing that they tell their daughters it isn't just about looks, or that the learn confidence, how to compete, poise, etc, but who the frig are they kidding? If you put a little girl dressed to the nine's in full blown make up etc on a stage being judged by people, what exactly IS she thinking? She's thinking I look beautiful and pretty. Enough said.

    Report Abuse
  • Mammina's Avatar
    Posted by Mammina Thu Nov 5, 2009 8:22am PST

    Kids should be left to play and enjoy their childhood. Young kids at the age of 3 or 4 don't give a damn if they win or loose, their mummies do but!!

    Report Abuse
  • H's Avatar
    Posted by H Thu Nov 5, 2009 8:27am PST

    No it is not healthy.

    Report Abuse
  • Elm's Avatar
    Posted by Elm Thu Nov 5, 2009 8:30am PST

    Is it me or does that little girl look just like a younger Katherine Heigle?

    Report Abuse
  • QueenofSpades's Avatar
    Posted by QueenofSpades Thu Nov 5, 2009 9:34am PST

    I've had the displeasure of working with 2 crownheads, as they call themselves, and they tend to be snotty and self-absorbed yet not really functional. That's the two people I worked with. I didn't like either and all they seem to care about is the next pageant and serious insecurity issues - constant need for attention. My daughter is 3 years old and I've been approached about getting her in pageants or modeling and then I see shows like Crowns & Tiaras...so disgusted by those parents...I notice they usually are hacks themselves so push those poor kids to do what they themselves kind never do. Not my cup of tea.

    Report Abuse
  • Mo B's Avatar
    Posted by Mo B Thu Nov 5, 2009 9:57am PST

    I've had people tell me since the day my daughter was born that I should put her into modeling. I have always said that I think it sends the wrong message. I do not want my child growing up thinking her main asset is her looks, I want her to use her brain. At the same time i think to each their own, just not my child no way. When she is older and can actualy make decisions on her own she can do whatever she wants but not while I'm still raising her will she ever make money based on how she looks.

    Report Abuse
  • Katie's Avatar
    Posted by Katie Thu Nov 5, 2009 10:15am PST

    Pagents are just ridiculous, and should be against the law. Parents sign their kids up for this BS then when the girl starts to grow she wants to end her life because suddenly she's not rail thin anymore and "cute" anymore... Pagents are pathetic, and teach little girls NOTHING about real life.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 51

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.