Parenting

Monday, November 30, 2009

Crabmommy: Are you raising your child to be gender-neutral?

I thought I was a feminist until I gave birth to one. "What do you think of our snowman?" I asked Crabkid last week after we made use of the unusual snowfall in the Pacific Northwest.

"Not a snowman, a snowgirl," she corrected me. "It's a girl."

For as long as she has been able to speak, Crabkid has displayed feminist tendencies, reminding me that we still live in a man's world and that even I have grown complacent within it. Take that snowgirl. Why not? Why should a sexless hump of snow with a scarf and buttons be masculine? After all the carrot's on the top tier of the snowballs, not sticking out between or below.

Having never gone so far as to call history "herstory" or ripping the "e" out of "women" to replace it with a "y," I still used my macho father's money well in college by writing some decent patriarchy-dissing critiques of classic lit. And while I've always taken care to use gender-inclusive pronouns, I apparently still think man-first thoughts: "What a cute scarecrow!" I said to Crabkid, on seeing a cute fall creature propped up on a haystack outside Whole Foods this fall. "Isn't he cute?"

"She," Crabkid corrected me. "It's a girl." Again, why not? So the scarecrow is wearing pants! Big deal? The crotch is flat, the straw hair is long (not that this should mean anything in today's shaggy-boy times). Indeed, in this androgynous era, my kid reminds me that I'm not as "with it" and gender-neutral as I think.

The feminist inclination in Crabkid extends to everything and everyone in her range. Like many little girls of four, she prefers girls. From princesses to playmates, she favors girl-oriented things and people. In fact she's less impressed with Santa than she is with Mrs. Claus. "I think Mrs. Claus delivers the presents," she told me last night. "Maybe Santa just wraps them."

Related: The girliest obsession of all: the color pink.)

As much as possible Crabkid uses the word "she"—even when, occasionally, she's just plum wrong: "What a sweet boy," I crooned to the pet rabbit—Benji—my mother got for Crabkid when we visited her in Africa last year. Again I was corrected and told "Benji is a girl!" This time I corrected back, because Benji really was a boy and I don't want Crabkid to be sexist and not like boys at all! But at the thought of Benji being a boy, Crabkid's eyes just glazed over with boredom. She lost interest, wandered off to play with her dolls. "Maybe she is a girl," I relented, eager to have Crabkid appreciate this wild bunny, which my mother went to such lengths to procure and which was destroying her house, tunneling under the pool and dropping rabbit pellets beneath the beds. Such a wonderful little girl, that Benji!

The "she" pronoun follows our family everywhere now and extends to encompass a range of sexless things too. I no longer bat an eyelash in describing trees, books, and basically anything fantastic as feminine. Even our manly-looking car is a girl. Her name is Rose.

But Crabkid couldn't quite get her head around the fact that a male nurse checked her up at the ER recently, when we overreacted to a croupy cough at the crack of dawn. "He's a nurse?" she asked me after the fellow had left the room. "That's weird," she said. And then she asked for her blanket, whose name is Green Girl. "Green Girl, isn't it funny that nurse is a boy?"

Anyone else have a feminist about the house? Or is it a boys' club at yours?

Related: Why do women prefer to have girls? One mom recounts her tale of gender disappointment.

More from Crabmommy:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 30
  • Melinda's Avatar
    Posted by Melinda Mon Dec 22, 2008 3:08pm PST

    Because of the story "Frosty the SnowMAN" Retard! He's a snow MAN not a snow woman! It's a mans world and your just livin in it!! Get used to it! Hilary didn't make office...you know why? It's a mans world!!!

    Report Abuse
  • lm's Avatar
    Posted by lm Mon Dec 22, 2008 6:54pm PST

    Its a mans world???

    Women have always run the checkbook, always controlled the sex etc

    No, its a shared world

    why cant some women stop proving the stereotype that whining is the way to get what you want

    If you ,as a women, are out there kickin butt then ITS YOUR WORLD

    If a mans world is so wrong, per all the feminist pablum, then why do they strive so hard to be like the men?

    Women say they dont need men but then have baby after baby without marriage and get assistance from.......drum roll please......... men

    We need each other ESPECIALLY WHEN CHILDREN ARE INVOLVED and your child saying a SNOWGIRL doesnt indicate feminism at work

    Equality isnt really what feninists wanted otherwise they would have protest AGAINST their better treatment at restaurants or women get in for free , men pay etc

    Report Abuse
  • KristaB's Avatar
    Posted by KristaB Tue Dec 23, 2008 12:17am PST

    ...good for her...and you...i wonder if i still have time to bake gingerbread women...

    Report Abuse
  • Sandy's Avatar
    Posted by Sandy Tue Dec 23, 2008 8:08am PST

    Kids say the darndest things and they always are cute. Let her have her female empowerment. It really helps with macho-chauvenistic jerks like melindajaao up there... Isn't Melinda a girl's name?

    Report Abuse
  • MeganD's Avatar
    Posted by MeganD Tue Dec 23, 2008 8:55am PST

    When my little sister was young she would say she wanted a "girl cheese, not a boy cheese" when asking for a grilled cheese sandwich!

    Report Abuse
  • Chana C's Avatar
    Posted by Chana C Tue Dec 23, 2008 9:12am PST

    I think raising kids completely gender neutral can be a bad thing. I don't mean teach them stereotypes about what a certain gender can't do or should do. Instead teach them that there is nothing wrong with being a woman, or a man, and to embrace their gender while moving ahead in this world. It seems like to often we push our daughters to not like anything that would be considered "girly" and teach our sons that being male somehow makes them evil. Instead introduce your daughter to male nurses, female doctors, and a wide variety of people in different roles. That way she can grow up learning that a woman can hold any job she works for or achieve any goals without having to become gender neutral and give up her feminine side.

    It's normal for kids to learn and discover things about themselves, which includes gender. When you daughter or son enters school, or preschool, then they will also have peer influences regarding gender. You may have debates with your bundle of joy that just because she saw some boys wearing blue doesn't mean that it is a "boy" color and she can't wear it. She may also come with you with questions or other debates about what is for boys and what is for girls. It's part of learning the gender roles of the society. It doesn't mean sticking to out of date roles or stereotypes, but there will come a day when you have to explain to her that in this society it's not ok for a woman to go out topless in summer like it is for the men, and why her male friend's mom may get mad at her for playing makeover with him and using lipstick.

    Report Abuse
  • Ken's Avatar
    Posted by Ken Tue Dec 23, 2008 10:19am PST

    To Chana...AMEN!!! (oops, should I have said AWOMEN?) Face it left wingers, there are two genders and both should be celebrated. Frosty is a MALE, Rudolph is a MALE, Dora the Explorer is FEMALE. Gender neutrality...what a laugh.

    Report Abuse
  • April Hughes's Avatar
    Posted by April Hughes Tue Dec 23, 2008 1:23pm PST

    Good thing she doesn't speak french or spanish, where everything is male or female "El carro", etc. I thought it was interesting that those languages masculize (is that word), or feminize all words. I think she is going through that just because she is a girl and when you are little the world revolves around you, and since she is a girl everyone else should be too!

    Report Abuse
  • Renaissancegirl's Avatar
    Posted by Renaissancegirl Tue Dec 23, 2008 1:37pm PST

    That's one little 4 year old girl who would absolutely annoy the pee out of me. She's not a feminist - she's a sexist, and one has to wonder how someone of the very young age of 4 has already developed that outlook.

    Report Abuse
  • amanda d's Avatar
    Posted by amanda d Tue Dec 23, 2008 2:45pm PST

    My daughter expresses when people, stuffed animals, barbies, and other toys (with eyes, nose, and mouths, are boy are girl and sometimes (loudly) asks if men with long hair are girls, and women with short hair are boys. Sometimes she says things like nurses are girls and doctors are men. I do not teach her that women are nurses, and men doctors. Actually, I explain that boys or girls can be either. I don't want her to grow up thinking she has to be better than men or that she is not as good as men. I want her to think she needs to be the best she can be period and whatever she chooses.

    However, I did ask my daugher and her snowman would be a girl(my daughter just turned 4).

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 30

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.